Which US President Should be Added to Mount Rushmore?

The iconic Mount Rushmore National Memorial, located in the Black Hills of South Dakota, features four of the United States' most prominent and influential presidents: George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, and Abraham Lincoln. However, questions and discussions continue about potential additions to this renowned monument. Let's explore the arguments and considerations for adding a new president to Mount Rushmore.

Preservation and Tradition

Some argue that adding a new president to Mount Rushmore is not worth the risk. The integrity of the current monument is paramount, and any attempt to add a new face would require destructive alterations to the existing sculpture. As Steven noted, 'My vote would be for FDR… no president since that time has had to deal with the challenges he did to preserve the nation through the greatest economic disaster in US history and then lead the nation through the greatest war in human history … all while being partially paralyzed from polio.' However, the fear of altering the finished work and potentially causing irreversible damage leads many to advocate for maintaining the current status quo.

The Torch Bearer

While some suggest adding Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR), others like John consider it unresolved. Euler13 emphasizes, 'There's no President who could command support from a solid majority of Americans.' Even if FDR is proposed, it's often suggested as a compromise, acknowledging his profound impact yet maintaining the sanctity of the monument. Others like Sam express the view that 'It’s a classic case of one more will end all. Any attempt to further carve that mountain will see it all fall away.'

Ethical and Ecological Considerations

The ecological and ethical implications of adding a new president to Mount Rushmore are also significant. The mountain itself is sacred to the Lakota people, and modifications could be seen as disrespectful or harmful. Derek and Tom both echo concerns about the instability in the rocks, making any alterations practically impossible. Ben elaborates, 'The mountain is unstable and it’s sacred to the Lakota. Adding any more to it is ecologically and ethically a bad idea.'

Alternative Landmarks

For those who feel the current Monument needs to honor more presidents, there are other options. The Jefferson Memorial in Washington, D.C., stands as a fitting tribute to Thomas Jefferson. Its design focuses on the second president's legacy and achievements, providing a personal reflection rather than a massive, carved monument.

Humor or Satire?

A less conventional proposal suggests adding a humorous touch to Mount Rushmore. David once jokingly suggested, 'America could use some humor so I would like to see a penis carved there with the word TRUMP. He's truly a blathering dickhead.' While such a suggestion is purely for amusement, it highlights the playful and often controversial nature of discussions surrounding Mount Rushmore.

Setting Ideology Aside

When setting political ideology aside, many agree that Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) is the most significant modern addition to the Mount Rushmore Monument. John Adams makes a compelling case, stating, 'Seems to me that FDR is the clear pick. He’s not a hero of mine but I can’t see who else deserves consideration.' FDR's leadership during the Great Depression and World War II is unparalleled, making him a fitting tribute to the enduring spirit of the nation.

Concluding Thoughts

The discussion around adding a new president to Mount Rushmore highlights the balancing act between preserving historical monuments and honoring the contributions of lesser-known but impactful leaders. The current monument stands as a reminder of the legacy of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt, and Abraham Lincoln, and any consideration to alter this must be approached with the utmost respect and caution. For now, Mount Rushmore remains a symbol of American history, and the inclusion of FDR serves as a reminder of the critical role he played in shaping the nation.