Is a 7-Day Caribbean Cruise More Economical than a Resort Stay for a Family of 4?

Introduction to Travel Preferences

When it comes to deciding on a vacation for your family, both cruise and resort stays offer unique experiences. As someone who has taken 60 cruises and two all-inclusive resorts, I understand the allure of either option. However, let's put my bias to the test by comparing a recent Royal Caribbean cruise with a Beaches Family resort stay in Jamaica. On July 27, 2019, a stateroom with a balcony on the Symphony of the Seas cost $5,523.52 for four passengers, including taxes. A room at the Beaches Family resort on the same date cost $4,961.70 for the same number of people.

This example may seem like a close call, but it's important to consider the differences between the two experiences. For instance, while the resort stay may include sodas and alcohol, a cruise offers a variety of activities, entertainment, and menus that change daily. The cruise will also take you to three different countries with three distinct cultures: Dutch/French, Spanish, and Creole, providing a diverse and engaging experience for the entire family.

Cost Analysis of Cruise Options

The cost of a cruise can seem economical at first glance, but it's crucial to consider all potential extra charges. While some cruise lines advertise discounts and lower fees, such as free beverage packages, specialty dining, and kids' go-free, it's important to check with your agent because these promotions do not always apply to all sailings. Additionally, even with discounts on beverage packages, there is still a nominal charge. The specialty dining deal is also not free; you need to be aware that you will still incur some additional costs.

Other hidden costs include taxes, port charges, insurance, airfare, hotel gratuities, excursions, some drinks (if you don’t take the package), specialty dining (if you didn’t take the package), photographs taken by ship personnel, spa services, and souvenirs or items sold on board. By breaking down these potential extra costs, you can get a clearer picture of the total cost of a cruise.

Cost Analysis of Resort Stays

Resorts, on the other hand, offer a more straightforward cost structure. All-inclusive resorts often cover airfare, hotel, all attractions, meals, beverages, and sometimes even gratuities. This can make it easier to budget and ensures that you hardly need your wallet, unless you want souvenirs or to reward staff for exceptional service.

For families, there are family resorts and for adults-only, there are private adult-only resorts. These resorts are usually in a confined area with a variety of activities, often near a beach or pool, allowing families to enjoy organized activities for kids while parents can have some downtime. This feature also applies to many cruise lines, providing a balance between family fun and relaxation.

Final Thoughts and Decision Factors

Both cruise and resort stays have their merits, and the best choice depends on personal preferences and variables, such as the ages of the travelers and the type of activities preferred. To help you make an informed decision, express your wishes to a travel advisor who can lay out the pros and cons of each option and help you determine which is the best fit for your budget and needs.

While family cruises can offer a more diverse and dynamic experience, resort stays can provide a more streamlined and budget-friendly option. Ultimately, the choice depends on what you and your family value the most in your vacation.