The Debate: GT vs. Super

When discussing the Dragon Ball franchise, one inevitably comes across the comparison between Dragon Ball GT and Dragon Ball Super. The narrative surrounding these two series has polarized fans, with opinions often swinging back and forth. Some argue that while GT had its moments, it falls short of the high standards established by subsequent installments like Super. However, others maintain that GT stands as a testament to the series's evolution and has its unique merits, regardless of how it stacks up against newer installments.

Assessing Dragon Ball GT

Dragon Ball GT, while popular among certain fandoms, is often criticized for its unconventional plot and story elements. Fans of the original series, Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z, find GT to be a departure from the norm. The rushed character development, awkward storylines, and cringe-inducing moments are frequently pointed out as drawbacks.

Of course, not all fans share this opinion. Some appreciate the unique narrative arcs and character interactions that GT brings to the table. The series explores a different side of the Dragon Ball universe, introducing new elements that can be engaging for many viewers. However, these elements often come at the cost of consistency and character continuity.

Evolution of Standards

The argument that GT was somehow good because of the perceived shortcomings of Dragon Ball Super highlights a broader issue: the evolution of anime standards. Over time, fans have become more critical and well-informed, expecting a higher level of consistency and quality in their entertainment. While GT may have been praised in its own time, its flaws are now more apparent compared to modern adaptations.

Comparing GT to Super is like comparing apples to oranges. GT is a filler series, designed to capitalize on the success of the original series and extend the franchise. In contrast, Super is a more deliberate and comprehensive continuation, aimed at advancing the story and evolving the characters. This evolution in storytelling is what has led to higher standards in the franchise, and it's why GT is often seen as a step back.

Character and Plot Flaws

One of the most significant criticisms of Dragon Ball GT is its character development and plot coherence. The sudden introduction of new characters and story arcs without proper integration can be jarring for long-time fans. The rushed pacing and lack of character development often leave viewers feeling disconnected from the characters they love.

In addition to these issues, the narrative complexity of GT often falls flat. The casual insertion of deities and the abrupt changes in the overarching storyline can be confusing and detract from the overall enjoyment of the series. This is in stark contrast to the more intricate and logically consistent storylines present in Dragon Ball Super and Dragon Ball Z.

Conclusion and Reevaluation

While Dragon Ball GT may have had its moments, it ultimately fails to meet the high standards set by subsequent installments. The narrative that GT is good because of the perceived shortcomings of Dragon Ball Super is a flawed logic. The evolution of the Dragon Ball universe and the rise of more sophisticated storytelling have raised the bar for what fans expect from their entertainment.

Ultimately, the enjoyment of any series comes down to personal preference. While some may find GT appealing for its unique elements, it is important to recognize the larger context and the standards set by the franchise. The debate between GT and Super is not only about which is better but also about the evolution of the anime medium and the changing tastes of its audience.