Is American Culture Being Diluted by Progressives?
Is American Culture Being Diluted by Progressives?
Is American culture being diluted by progressives? This question often sparks heated debate. American culture is a rich tapestry of diverse influences, reflecting the multi-faceted nature of its society. Traditions from early English settlers have been woven together with contributions from later waves of immigrants, including Irish, Polish, Italian, and Swedish. Now, progressives are adding to this cultural mix, bringing fresh ideas and perspectives.
Progressives and Cultural Influence
Lin-Manuel Miranda's Broadway musical Hamilton is a prime example. This masterpiece not only entertains but also educates its audiences about American history. However, Miranda's precise political stance might be somewhat ambiguous, but there's no doubt that he identifies as a progressive. The show's success highlights how progressive ideas can permeate into mainstream culture, influencing how we understand and appreciate our history.
American Culture After Television
It's widely acknowledged that American culture underwent a significant shift around 1970 with the widespread adoption of television. Before this era, local and personal influences dominated. The advent of television and subsequent media platforms introduced a more standardized, corporate version of culture. This shift away from authentic, local cultures contributed to a more homogenized national culture.
Attitudinal Changes in American Society
Joe Biden's statement about the younger generation being the least prejudiced compared to previous generations holds a lot of truth. There is a marked increase in biracial families and a more open-minded attitude towards diversity. As the older generation fades, these attitudes are likely to become more the norm. This change is not just progressive in terms of politics but also in social acceptance and cultural practices. The future looks increasingly inclusive, and this is something to embrace.
Immigration and the Evolution of American Culture
It's important to recognize that American culture has always been a product of various influences. Each wave of immigration has contributed significantly, from Irish to Polish to Italian to Swedish. This ongoing process of cultural dilution has not diminished the American identity but has enriched it. Progressives, with their emphasis on inclusivity and progress, are just the latest in a long line of groups contributing to the evolution of American culture.
In the 2020 presidential elections, progressives actually outvoted conservatives, suggesting that the mainstream culture is moving towards more progressive values. However, the term 'dilution' may be misleading. Instead, it might be more accurate to say that American culture is evolving into a more progressive mainstream.
The Role of Progress in Culture and Civilization
Civilization and progress are intrinsically linked. Cultures must adapt and evolve to remain relevant and effective in the face of new challenges. For instance, advancements in healthcare, such as vaccines, are not just beneficial to individual health but to the broader civilization. They are a logical and necessary step to inoculate society against diseases, much like how progressive changes help us grow as a nation.
On the other hand, culture at times can take a defensive stance that hinders progress. Just as rejecting vaccines can harm public health, rejecting progressive ideas can damage societal cohesion and progress. For example, a Christian Scientist opting out of vaccination for cultural reasons puts not only themselves but also their community at risk. Similarly, clinging to outdated cultural norms can prevent society from making progress and growing.
In conclusion, American culture is undoubtedly changing, but this shift towards more progressive values is natural and beneficial. Instead of viewing it as dilution, we should see it as a process of continuous evolution that enriches our society and helps us face new challenges.